New Bethel Ordinary

05/13/2008 Posted by Lisa8033

Our family of 4 has been to NBO several times and we love it. From the Prime Rib (for my 78 year old mother),the Beef Manhattan (for my 12 year old daughter) and the great pizza. My husband and I have been there for the lunch specials (way too much food to eat) and for breakfast. We have had a "grouchy" waitress before, however we have only seen her on one visit. Everyone seems nice to us. You do have to get there a little early on Saturday evenings. We meet friends there who live 30 minutes away, they love the pizza and don't mind the drive either.

Pros: Great Pizza

Cons: Not enough parking

05/25/2007 Posted by margaretwalker

Our team usually does the Donatoes for lunch but someone had tried the Wanamaker Ordinary and suggested that we try it. She said that the toppings were stacked up thick. We don't stray from the norm too often but decided to try it. WOW!!! Absolutely fantastic. We had 11 people eating on two supreme 16' party cut pizzas and had almost a whole pizza left. Everyone was commenting that the pizza was delicious and they were so full!! I would say that as far as Pizza goes this little restaurant off of the beaten path is definately OUT OF THE ORDINARY in a very delicious way!!

Pros: Good price, good food

04/13/2007 Posted by bigmac10914

my family has been a fan of new bethel ordinary for at least two years, and even with the slight price increase the pizza is completely worth it! i can only eat one slice; it is truly the BEST pizza in indy/wannamaker. never disapointed; always delicious!

Pros: only for die hard pizza coniseurs!

Cons: not enough parking spaces on a busy night; carry out is difficult at times. smoking patrons

04/04/2007 Posted by mastercooney

My parents live near the Ordinary(within walking distance), and whenever i am there we always get either a supreme pizza, or go for my personal favorite for breakfast, brains & eggs. This is most definitely the best pizza i have ever had and think that it could go up as one of the best pizzas in the country.

Pros: Amazing Pizza, Great breakfast menu, Variety on menu, Very good home-town feel, its in wanamaker

Cons: none whatsoever

01/08/2007 Posted by nomoredrama

The pizza is just OK. Lotsof cheese, which is a plus. The crust was decent. Although I found the amount of pepperoni to be too much,as it was about all I tasted. VERY SLOW SERVICE- EVEN ON TAKE_OUT! Seating is cramped in dining area and I would recommend take-out. The parking is ridiculously scant. You will drive around for a parking space, if you go at peak time.

Pros: lots of cheese

Cons: parking, service and price

02/16/2006 Posted by aprylbaby

food was okay.service was very scary. couldnt get refills or a smile.sorry if see was having a bad day but not my fault.

Pros: nice crane game

Cons: better service

02/13/2006 Posted by indycityphan

Went with a two time visitor who highly recommended the place. She was looking forward to it. It was my first visit. Waitress obviously was having a bad day, at least with us, cause she seem to find smile with the regulars. The pizza was definitely not the pie that everyone else speaks of and the taste was nothing special. My friend even asked if someone new was making the pizza cause it was so different than what she remembered from two weeks previous. We also had appetizers but they too were nothing out of the Ordinary.

12/22/2005 Posted by jimbojones46203

Our business is up the street about 5 minutes and our employees eat at NBO almost everyday. The food and service are always outstanding. The pizza is, hands down, the best in Indiana and one of the best in the US of A.

Pros: Great Value, Great Food

Cons: Crowded, Limited Parking

06/02/2005 Posted by akolanowski

I took my family to New Bethel Ord. at a friends suggestion, it was the best pizza that we ever had. Loaded with fresh toppings; nice and hot. Normally we have to order two pizzas for our family of six, but one from New Bethel was more than enough.

05/19/2005 Posted by bossman50

I have traveled the world in the last 25 years, and have eaten pizza wherever I could. This ranks as one of the 4 best pizzas I have ever tasted, as long as it's loaded up. I tried a cheese one and it was pretty bland, but if all you want is cheese, get a frozen one from the store. The value is also sensational. Where else can you feed 2 adults and three teenagers for 17 bucks. The official "stomp" of approval!