Reviews & Ratings for Nancy's Pizzeria

11/19/05

Great Stuffed Pizza

by manotherm at Citysearch

If you love cheese you need to have this pizza. I dont know what blend they use but its nice and fluffy.....just wonderful. We order take out from this pizzeria at least once a month and we have never had a bad stuffed pizza. Being from Chicago its like a piece of home! A can't vouch for their thin crust though since I feel I've had better in the area.

• Pros: Always good, Fast delivery, Great Pizza

05/25/05

User review by thegoose

by thegoose at Citysearch

The thin crust pizza's cost too much and they aren't anything special. The stuffed pizzas are good. I would not recommend dining in at all. The customer service is very lacking. The kids who work the counter are fine, but when it comes to problems with orders or complaints, you might as well not waste your time.

• Cons: Bad Service, Expensive

05/15/05

NANCYS!

by nuttyzebra at Citysearch

I LOVE JAKE WRAY!!!! and also Nancy's Pizza!!!!!!! BUT I LOVE JAKE MORE!!!!!!!!

05/09/05

User review by agentbump

by agentbump at Citysearch

I have not eaten any pizza or pasta other than Nancy's ever since they opened a few years ago! Both thin and Chicago style stuffed are the best in the city. And the pastas are not only tasty, they are huge portions. The price may appear higher than those "fast food" pizza places, but the amount and quality of food you get at Nancy's makes it a tremendous value.

I have also taken part in their lunch catering services and they cannot be beat. Besides the great, hot food, they deliver drinks, ice, plates, and utensils. All I have to do is place the order and show up at the lunch! That's a huge relief in my crazy day.

If you haven't tried Nancy's Chicago style stuffed pizza yet, you have no idea what you are missing!

• Pros: value, taste, catering delivery

05/08/05

Great Pizza & Pasta!

by jillc at Citysearch

I have enjoyed Nancy's pizza for the past year and have recently used them for catering work lunches. I highly recommend the pastas, especially the chicken tetrazini. Delivery is prompt and the customer service is stellar.

• Pros: Chicago style pizza, great service, unbelievable pasta

08/14/04

NOT LIKE CHICAGO

by jessicacd at Citysearch

Awful! Undercooked pizza! RUDE SERVICE! RECEIVED NO FOLLOW UP TO MY COMPLAINTS! Very Expensive.

Not at all like the Nancys in Chicago

• Cons: , terrible service, undercooked food

03/14/04

Yummy

by susanfletcher at Citysearch

I am from Chicago and have not had good pizza since arriving in Indiana ten years ago. Nancy's definitely has that Chicago pizza flavor, being originally from Chicago. I highly recommend it if you especially like deep dish and stuffed pizza. If you don't know what that is, you need to try it.

• Pros: Taste, Chicago Pizza, Inexpensive