Castleton Grill
Indianapolis, IN 46250-1525
Phone: (317) 577-2340
User Reviews for Castleton Grill
05/10/2008 Posted by Al386
My friend and I randomly found this place on our way back from Chicago, and we were pleasently surprised. They had a wood fired oven, and we both got grilled chicken dishes. The flavor was amazing. For dessert we got the brownie sundae, which was so warm, moist, and delicious. If this place was in my hometown I would definately eat there frequently.
Pros: delicious food
Cons: none
11/08/2007 Posted by sueehamm
We've been to Castleton Grill three times and never again, all three times have been terrible! This third time, we were in a party of six adults. Salad was good and fresh, baked potato was good...four of us had ordered the Sirloin...all four complained that the steaks were tough! Mine was so tough it had to be "sawed" to cut it...the three bites that I took could never be chewed up, so ultimately those bites ended up in my napkin. In addition, I had ordered medium, but it was more like raw. The waitress said she could take it back, but I said "no" because that would not have improved the toughness. My husband ordered the pork chops...they were so tough that he only ate a few bites. Third time definitely wasn't the charm!
Pros: Fresh salad
Cons: Tough steak
