Taylor's Bakery

Recommends

tntmuth

Joined 7 years ago

The BEST cakes in Indiana!. I will say that Taylor's has the best cakes I have EVER tasted! I have tasted pastrys and cakes from all over the world, and there is something unique about the Taylors taste. I get all of our birthday cakes from them...they also have the best designs for cakes, especially for kids themed parties!

Recommends

wundrwomynn

Joined 9 years ago

The real deal!. We ordered one of their angel food cakes for a birthday, which is one of their specialties. it was light, fluffy, fresh, and delicious. And inexpensive! While there, we sampled a few other specialties which were all good. They also have gourmet flavored popcorn now. Nice atmosphere, good service, feels like a neighborhood hangout where everyone knows the customers.

Doesn't Recommend

catgrin

Joined 8 years ago

dry cake!. Over the holidays I needed a dessert and quick! I stopped in at Taylors, got a pre-made white cake, took it the the dinner party and everyone commented on how horrible it was...dry and bad paste!

Haven't been back since, perhaps it was a fluke.?

Recommends

Contributor

Joined 10 years ago

Wedding cakes are the specialty of this 91-year-old bakery.. In Short
Taylor's, which calls itself "Indiana's oldest bakery" (est. 1913), is a place for everything from a mini-cannoli to a multi-tiered wedding cake. Wedding cakes dominate the display cases, and Taylor's boasts it can have them ready in one day. Another specialty is iced angel food cakes, which come in a variety of flavors. There's also a large selection of doughnuts, cookies and pastries.