The BEST cakes in Indiana!. I will say that Taylor's has the best cakes I have EVER tasted! I have tasted pastrys and cakes from all over the world, and there is something unique about the Taylors taste. I get all of our birthday cakes from them...they also have the best designs for cakes, especially for kids themed parties!
The real deal!. We ordered one of their angel food cakes for a birthday, which is one of their specialties. it was light, fluffy, fresh, and delicious. And inexpensive! While there, we sampled a few other specialties which were all good. They also have gourmet flavored popcorn now. Nice atmosphere, good service, feels like a neighborhood hangout where everyone knows the customers.
Over the holidays I needed a dessert and quick! I stopped in at Taylors, got a pre-made white cake, took it the the dinner party and everyone commented on how horrible it was...dry and bad paste!
Haven't been back since, perhaps it was a fluke.?
Wedding cakes are the specialty of this 91-year-old bakery..
Taylor's, which calls itself "Indiana's oldest bakery" (est. 1913), is a place for everything from a mini-cannoli to a multi-tiered wedding cake. Wedding cakes dominate the display cases, and Taylor's boasts it can have them ready in one day. Another specialty is iced angel food cakes, which come in a variety of flavors. There's also a large selection of doughnuts, cookies and pastries.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!