Aunt Polly's South

(317) 632-3663

2959 E Michigan St
Indianapolis, IN 46201 39.7745 -86.1133

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Central Indianapolis

4 Star Rating: Recommended

02/18/08

Keep Up The Great Food!!!!!

by MCousin49

I am a previous resturaunt owner. I have been ordering from Aunt Polly's for some years now. I can't see well behind the counters nor did I see a board of health inspection but, I know that I have gotten some really good food from here. I kind of grade resturaunts by my standards and the "Big Breaded Tenderloin" is off the the hook. It's not a place to go seat and expect to have a candle lite dinner but for some good food delivered or to go from the hood it's great. In comparison to some other up scaled resturaunts they have done a great job with pizza, sandwiches and desserts.

  • Pros: Easy access and delivery service
  • Cons: Need a larger eat in area, to attract customers who want a sit down meal
2 Star Rating: Below Average

02/11/08

Not in the summer!

by Mergentroid

Aunt Polly's is truly a great food delivery place, and probly the best in Indy in my honest opinion.

On the other hand however, I choose other sources for my food delivery needs in the hotter months of the year. The main reason for this is that Aunt Polly's isn't air conditioned. I have had a couple experiences when picking up an order in the hot months, that I could not believe. I know the temperature in that kitchen had to be at least 140-150 degrees. Then I see open, (probably refrigerated), but still open topping tables for the pizzas. I got to looking at the pizza table and noticed that the cheese was actually melting before it was put on the pizza. That tells me that the cheese was subjected to above safe temperatures, and could easily spoil in a very short period of time like that. What about the sausage? Or the beef? Sure, I love all those toppings hot when the pizza comes out of the oven, but I'd prefer that they be properly refrigerated BEFORE being put on the pizza. YUK!! When you really think about it, the employees are bending over the cheese with sweat pouring off their faces into it. Maybe that makes the cheese and other toppings more tasty? The more I thought about it, the more I realized what other unsanitary conditions could arise from such high temperatures in a food preparation facility. Why has the board of health not cited them for this? How can the employees even bare such inhumane working conditions? That alone tells me a lot about who ever owns this buisness. There is no way that they could possibly have any sincere regards, or compassion for the safety of their empolyees. Heat stroke, heat exaustion/cramps could easilly occur on an overworked employee in such temperatures. On each occaision I visited, (which has only been a couple times in summer), they were always busy. I could keep writing ,but I think we are getting the idea. DON'T ORDER IN THE SUMMER!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/05/08

best pizza anywhere

by cindijo25

Aunt Polly's Pizza is by far the best I have ever had. You can tell this restaurant is going to be around a long time. The way that the owners of this restaurant take pride in what they do. I have never been somewhere that actually cares about their customers the way they do. I have had nothing but the best service ever, the most friendlyest staff and the best pizza. If you are looking for something different try Aunt Pollys they deliver just about anywhere.

  • Pros: food, service andprice
  • Cons: parking

The Details on Aunt Polly's South

Category:

Pizza, Restaurants

Payment Methods:

Visa, Discover, MasterCard

Cuisine:

Pizza

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Aunt Polly's South

Aunt Polly's South

2959 E Michigan St
Indianapolis, IN 46201

Recent Reviews In Indianapolis city

1 Star Rating: Poor

Some Guys Pizza Pasta Grill

6235 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Sushi On The Rocks

235 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN

1 Star Rating: Poor

Taj Of India Restaurant

5929 E 82ND St, Indianapolis, IN

1 Star Rating: Poor

Treat America

2120 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN

Advertisement