Incredible atmosphere, hard to find in central Indiana!.
I've been going here since I was about 14 or so (I'm 26), and I still make it an absolute must when I'm visiting home (I live in Los Angeles now).
Bill and Tracy, the owners, build a unique sense of community in their country-chic coffee house. Exposed brick, warm lighting, and effortless elegance make this place feel like it should be featured in a magazine. Truly a diamond in the rough.
They also will make custom gourmet cakes, as I used them for both high school and college graduation (A cherries and cream cake with candied edible flowers on top). Also check out their seasonal dinners they host. It's an intimate multiple course dinner party using fresh ingredients from the season. I went to the Autumn dinner last year and it was INCREDIBLE. Long story short, go here. It's great!